Skip to content
  • A MEMBER OF THE TRANSDIFFUSION BROADCASTING SYSTEM
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Tumblr
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
THIS IS MY 1960s from Transdiffusion

THIS IS MY 1960s from Transdiffusion

We grew up in the sixties and loved every minute of it!

Primary Menu THIS IS MY 1960s from Transdiffusion

THIS IS MY 1960s from Transdiffusion

  • What we watched
    • Lanning at Large
    • Back in time for TV
  • What we listened to
    • Thank Your Lucky Stars
  • Who we loved
    • Autograph album
  • How we lived
  • 1964 in depth
  • Home
  • Milton Shulman
  • All these talk programmes – they’re getting worse
  • Milton Shulman

All these talk programmes – they’re getting worse

Milton Shulman 6 July 2022 0

Milton Shulman rages over the quality of TV chat

Ireland's Saturday Night masthead
From Ireland’s Saturday Night for 16 January 1965

IF ANY FURTHER sign were needed of the fatigue and inertia now paralysing television it is the sudden proliferation of talk programmes.

While the eye is being increasingly neglected, the ear is assaulted and pummelled hour after hour by what one might call cauliflower TV. It leaves the ear battered, bruised and sorry for itself.

Some talk programmes like Not So [Much A Programme, More A Way Of Life] and On the Braden Beat divide equally between the eye and the ear. But The Eamonn Andrews Show, Three After Six, The Explorers, Division, Take It Or Leave It, Dateline, and, naturally, The Epilogue, are basically radio shows that make only peripheral use of the visual medium.

Dinosaurs

These dinosaurs of TV could have made their appearance on radio in the mid-thirties with hardly a change of format or script. In the pioneer days of TV they would have been dismissed by any progressive producer as a retrogressive admission of defeat.

But their appeal to TV board rooms and planning executives is obvious. Cauliflower TV often gets a favourable critical reception because it usually has about it an intellectual or cultural aura. And, above all, it is cheap.

For these programmes there are no heavy costs for the sets, scripts, travel, filming, editing, or performers. University dons, journalists, writers, and politicians – the backbone of these programmes – can be paid a fraction of the cost of actors, well-known comperes, and other professional entertainers in other shows.

I would guess that Rediffusion by putting on Three After Six (three people talking to each other) instead of Here and Now (a film and taped actuality show) the company is saving money at the rate of £30,000 to £40,000 [£650,000 to £900,000 now allowing for inflation -Ed] a year. Since they get as much official acclaim for one as the other, who can blame them?

It would be foolish, of course, to contend that there was no place for some talk programmes on TV. What concerns me, as much as the misuse of the medium, is the general deterioration and lowering of intellectual standards of the conversation we hear on TV as compared with what we used to hear on radio.

Exempted from this stricture is Rediffusion’s The Explorers, in which Jack Hargreaves makes a serious attempt to probe the minds of serious men to give us some insight about their thoughts about the future.

Monday’s discussion with Professor Denis Gabor about the impact of automation on our society and the problem of leisure left me tingling with intellectual excitement and curiosity.

Eamonn Andrews
Eamonn Andrews

Boring

But what ABC’s The Eamonn Andrews Show is supposed to be doing I have not yet discovered. Entertaining people, I will no doubt be told, proving once more that the word “entertaining” is often synonymous with boring, vulgarising and embarrassing.

When it first began its guests included a sprinkling of relatively serious people like Randolph Churchill, Wolf Mankowitz and Ogden Nash. But the inability of Mr. Andrews, as compere, to sustain any serious talk and the impossibility of mixing slapstick and profundity soon led to the elimination of almost everybody but entertainers and clowns.

On Sunday the show reach its nadir to date. Representing the entertainers were Michael Mac Llammoir and Jeanette Scott, and the clowns were Michael Frayn and the Earl of Arran.

If the conversation has kept its centre of gravity concentrated on such topics as whether or not all blondes were dumb or whether humour is male of female (these subjects were touched upon), one could have dismissed the subsequent inanity as TV fodder on the same level as the ill-fated Celebrity Game.

But Mr. Andrews steered the talk into deeper channels, and this ill-assorted group found themselves talking about automation, computers, racial prejudice, patriotism and conformity.

Foreigners

From the Earl of Arran we heard that “the Irish have never produced anybody worthwhile,” that the Swiss are “mean, snobbish and smelly,” and that “wogs begin at Calais and that all foreigners are “bloody.” [sic on quote marks]

Now there will be protests from viewers about the use of the word “bloody.” I doubt if many will object to the far more xenophobic sentiments of the earl’s mind.

No one on the programme, I should add, intelligently contradicted the noble earl. To their credit, they were probably too startled to do anything but gasp.

If Lord Hill and the ITA is really concerned about television corrupting the public mind, let them stop worrying about the number of times people are kicked in the groin in thrillers and think a bit about the number of times they are concussed on the brain by programmes like the Eamonn Andrews Show.

One rule Lord Hill might seriously think about is preventing so-called funny programmes from tackling subjects too important and too delicate for their capabilities.

The ITA does not list the Eamonn Andrews Show among its “serious” programmes but it does list On the Braden Beat. The distinction is valid and proper. It is, therefore, up to the ITA to make sure that we are protected from stupidity and ignorance about significant matters merely because it is masquerading in the jester’s garb of “light entertainment.”

I had intended this week to discuss, too, the quality and standard of other examples of cauliflower TV but, because of space, it will have to wait for another time.

Tags: ABC Weekend TV, Arthur Gore, Dateline, Denis Gabor, Division, Independent Television Authority, Jack Hargreaves, Jeanette Scott, Lord Hill of Luton, Michael Frayn, Micheál Mac Liammóir, Not So Much A Programme More A Way Of Life, Ogden Nash, On the Braden Beat, racism, Randolph Churchill, Rediffusion, Take It Or Leave It, The Explorers, Three After Six, Wolf Mankowitz

Continue Reading

Previous Is this the root of the trouble with Tonight?
Next Just for a change why doesn’t Panorama etc get out of the rut?

Related features

  • Milton Shulman

These are among the TV shows I call toothless and vapid

Milton Shulman 24 September 2023 0
  • Milton Shulman

He’s nasty and he’s a stoolpigeon yet a great many viewers like to see him

Milton Shulman 17 September 2023 0
  • Milton Shulman

Please don’t call me Emma pleads the eminently whistleable at Diana Rigg

Milton Shulman 10 September 2023 0

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Share

    Milton Shulman

  • These are among the TV shows I call toothless and vapid
  • He’s nasty and he’s a stoolpigeon yet a great many viewers like to see him
  • Please don’t call me Emma pleads the eminently whistleable at Diana Rigg
  • Was it right for the BBC to show all this brutality in the bullring?
  • The sporting life could be the death of us
  • This is television nowhere else in the world can match
  • ‘Mogul’ needs a new look at its womenfolk
  • 18 hours of old films in one week’s viewing is much too much
  • That Eamonn Andrews show – Is extermination too good for it?
  • The drivel and gush of the television serial
  • Frost warning; so the message is pull your socks up
  • I liked the garlanded Nelson play, but…
  • Oh, that maladjusted sense of humour!
  • A matter of a three letter word
  • Oh! those awful earbashing programmes
  • Ready, Steady, Go runs into imaginative paralysis
  • In a TV year That Never Was these were my worst programmes
  • Decadent and trashy – Is this YOUR view of Riviera Police
  • Hail the B.B.C. – It’s the most prolific comedy factory in the world
  • Some of the things Burke (of Burke’s Law) can teach Sherlock Holmes
  • Five pop shows on television to every two where they talk about politics
  • What a pity Mr. Jonathan Miller should lose his nerve
  • Just for a change why doesn’t Panorama etc get out of the rut?
  • All these talk programmes – they’re getting worse
  • Is this the root of the trouble with Tonight?

Sections

  • American Forces Network
  • Autograph album
  • Back in time for TV
  • How we lived
  • Introduction
  • Lanning at Large
  • Milton Shulman
  • Thank Your Lucky Stars
  • What we listened to
  • What we watched
  • Who we loved

We ♥︎ these sites

  • We Are Cult
  • Gypsy Creams
  • Stockport Plaza
  • Gavin Sutherland
  • KCEA 89.1FM
  • MACE
  • BFI Britain on Film
  • Round the North we go
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Subjects

1963 ABC Weekend TV Adam Faith AFN American Forces Network Associated TeleVision ATV ATV Midlands Back in time for TV BBC-1 BBC-2 BBC Radio 1 BBCtv Bonanza Bruce Forsyth Charlie Drake Coronation Street Danger Man Dave Lanning Doctor Who Dudley Moore Granada TV Network Kenny Everett Lanning at Large Lonnie Donegan Maverick Millicent Martin Picture Show Radio Times Ready Steady Go! Rediffusion Roy Hudd Thank Your Lucky Stars The Avengers The Baron The Beatles The Eamonn Andrews Show The Man from UNCLE The Saint Tom Jones! Tommy Steele Tonight TVTimes Val Parnell's Sunday Night at the London Palladium Watch With Mother

RSS On Transdiffusion

  • Grampian T.V.
    Opening night September 30th 1961
  • The fall and rise of TV-am
    As TV-am finally overtakes BBC Breakfast Time, the TVTimes takes a look back at the tumultuous first 3 years
  • And now… The Flying Camera
    You're about to see the world from a very unusual angle: straight down!
  • In Nine Months TV Transforms Wembley Studios
    Switching Wembley from film to television ready for the launch of ITV
  • This Autumn, Granada will be televising Parliament
    'First Among Equals' comes to ITV
 

Subscribe by email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

 
THIS IS TRANSDIFFUSION
✉ BCM Transdiffusion, LONDON WC1N 3XX

☎ 03333 391 247

ISSN: 2753-3484

FROM NORTHSTAR
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Tumblr
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
from TRANSDIFFUSION | CoverNews by AF themes.